Durban-Pietermaritzburg river pollution a microcosm of nationwide water pollution control failures
First published by GroundUp
by Tony Carnie
Sometimes, a really bad dose of pollution news can turn out to be good news.
Huh? How could another massive oil and chemical spill into one of the country’s most frequently polluted river systems possibly be seen as a blessing in disguise?
Earlier this year, around 30000 litres of edible cooking oil and caustic soda spilled from collapsed storage tanks at the Willowton Oil factory into a tributary of the Msunduzi River, scene of the historic Dusi Canoe Marathon between Pietermaritzburg and Durban.
Within a matter of days, fish, crabs and invertebrate life were all but wiped out from a 40km stretch of river.
Dead fish piled up on the banks of the Msunduzi River after the spill. Photo: Dusi Media Office
Though cooking oil is not toxic, the sticky liquid clogged the gills and breathing systems of fish and other water creatures – choking the life out of them, aquatic experts explained to delegates attending the annual Conservation Symposium near Howick last week
To make things worse, the August 13 spillage from the Pietermaritzburg industrial area also included a large quantity of caustic soda, a highly toxic chemical used to manufacture everyday products such as soap and detergents.
Within a matter of hours, the Baynespruit tributary resembled a bubble bath, a frothing mass of cooking oil and liquid detergent.
This tributary leads into the Msunduzi and uMngeni Rivers – ultimately draining into Inanda Dam, Durban’s largest fresh drinking water reservoir.
Faye Brownell, general manager of the Duzi Umngeni Conservation Trust (DUCT), a non-profit pollution monitoring and community education group, said municipal sewage spills into the Msunduzi River and tributaries had escalated dramatically over the last two years.
“The Baynespruit is one of the worst-polluted streams in the country, so you ask yourself: ‘Could it get any worse?’…. And then we had the Willowton spill!”
Dr Mark Graham, a senior aquatic scientist and director of the GroundTruth consultancy group, said response reports revealed that 1752 tonnes of vegetable oil and caustic soda flowed from the collapsed storage tanks at Willowton Oils. Of this, around 110 tonnes left the site of the spill. .
Experts called in
Graham is now part of a team of independent experts appointed to deal with the incident. He said that although a significant volume was recovered by oil spill teams, up to 20 tonnes ended up in the Darvill sewage works and another 20-30 tonnes remains in the environment post clean up.
Dr Mark Graham presented his provisional findings on the Willowton Oil spill at last week’s Conservation Symposium. Photo: Tony Carnie
He said many fish died immediately from the clogging effects of the oil, the toxicity of caustic soda and the crude soap that formed from the combination of oil and caustic soda. Over the ensuing days up to 15 tonnes of dead fish were removed from the river system as far down as Umfula Store on the Mngeni River – 51 kilometres downstream from the pollution source.
51,000 dead fish
“We assume that another five tonnes of dead fish were eaten by birds, otters and other scavengers, translating into about 51 000 dead fish (or 750 fish per linear kilometre).”
Graham said he was hopeful that some juvenile fish and other remnant aquatic life had survived in some of the back channels and water pools to start recolonising the river system – but it was likely that several fish species would have to be re-introduced back into the system and as part of the rehabilitation programme.
“The fact that the river has taken such a hit is clearly a concern,” said Brownell, noting that fish and invertebrates (tiny aquatic nunus) serve a vital role in cleaning up urban pollution and municipal sewage spills by processing E.coli (sewage bacteria) and other pollutants.
Interviewed soon after the Willowton spill, the Chairman of DUCT, Dave Still, said the disaster had considerably weakened the natural ability of the river system to deal with chronic pollution in a similar way a person with AIDS is not able to fight infection.
Chronic sewage leakages
Citizen scientists conduct regular monitoring of the uMsunduzi river, regularly reporting broken sewer infrastructure to the municipality. The sewer leak depicted in the first picture was reported to the local municipality in January. By the end of August it had still not been repaired. Photos: Supplied
For several decades, chronic sewage pollution in the Msunduzi catchment area has been a big issue. According to data collected by Umgeni Water, which has been doing weekly sampling of a number of sites around Pietermaritzburg for more than 30 years, an average 20 million litres of sewage is leaking or spilling from Pietermaritzburg’s sewers every day.
“So while authorities are, quite rightly, all over Willowton about their recent sins, what are they doing about this 20 million litres of sewage pollution, which happens every day?” asked an environmental scientist and canoeing enthusiast, who asked not to be named.
Apart from threatening the continuation of the now nearly 70 year old Dusi Canoe Marathon, the impacts this sewage pollution have been severe.
Dam turns green
“It is unhealthy for community gardens and for kids swimming in the river and it is steadily turning Inanda Dam green – more than 60 km from the source of the pollution,” said the paddler. “These days when we paddle the Dusi it is like pea green soup at the top of the dam, and still somewhat green at the overnight stop, about 14 km from the headwaters. This is not only a sign of a dam in distress – eutrophication is the technical term – but it will ultimately push up the cost of the purification of that water.”
Graham observed that the Willowton spill and ongoing sewage pollution in the Msunduzi catchment was a microcosm of many similar problems across the country, such as the Vaal River, where large volumes of untreated or poorly-treated sewage flows into the country’s rivers every second – mostly from municipal sewage works.
“Nearly 80% of municipal water treatment works are nationally non-compliant,” he said.
Brownell said DUCT hoped that one of the big lessons that emerged from this spill was that healthy rivers are vital to improve the quality of water and that NGOs and civil society play a vital role in monitoring and holding industry and government to account.
While Willowton has often been fingered in the past as a major river polluter, Brownell said DUCT had been impressed by Willowton’s commitment to change following the catastrophic spill.
“Willowton has realised that they are not just an isolated company in Ohrtmann Road, Pietermaritzburg – their potential impact extends as far as Inanda Dam and Durban’s drinking water. Willowton have shown commitment to making a difference going forward by signing a memorandum of agreement with the DUCT to establish the new Baynespruit Conservancy– so perhaps there is a silver lining to this affair.”
In a statement, Willowton said the conservancy would be guided by a stakeholder group, The Baynespruit Conservancy Steering Committee, comprising representatives of catchment-based community conservation groups, local civil society organisations, and local industry, and leading Willowton representatives.
Willowton steps up
The conservancy will develop project proposals and raise funds to incrementally achieve the goal of a healthy Baynespruit Stream.
“An immediate and guiding action of the Baynespruit Conservancy will be the commissioning of an catchment action and management plan to guide and prioritise the short, medium and longer-term activities of the conservancy. The action catchment management plan will also be funded by the Willowton Group,” reads the statement.
Brownell believes that in the coming years ‘hundreds of millions’ of rand will be needed ultimately to address a wide range of pollution and catchment degradation problems in both the Msunduzi and Mngeni rivers systems.
The problem is so big that we just can’t wait for government to solve everything. Ultimately every water user in the catchment needs to recognise the importance of restoring our catchment, so that we can continue to have enough water, of good quality, in the future. Water is everybody’s business!” said Brownell.
Graham also urged civil society to become more closely involved in gathering citizen-science data about river pollution in order to hold polluters accountable.
One such project is at the Shiyabazali informal settlement, close to the Howick Falls.
Here local residents and members of the “Enviro Champs” group have been using a simple, but accurate citizen science tool – the clarity tube – to monitor sewage pollution from the Howick waste water treatment works that ultimately flows into the Albert Falls Dam.
Of the 7 686 suspended solids readings over the last seven years, only 5% were within the general limit values.
Ayanda Lepheana is setting up an organisation in Mpophomeni township, close to Midmar Dam, to raise awareness about water conversation. Photo: Tony Carnie
“By gathering data we don’t have to say to the municipality or responsible agency: ‘We think you are polluting the river’. We can now say: ‘We know you are polluting the water’ because the effluent is not compliant with national standards.”
Local resident Ayanda Lepheana has been closely involved in setting up another group of Enviro Champs in the Mpophomeni township, close to Midmar Dam.
Lepheana, who is now a junior scientist at GroundTruth, said a major focus of the Mpophomeni Enviro Champs is to raise awareness and provide education about water conservation and pollution to fellow residents.
The Enviro Champs are collecting data on blockages and sewer overflows by monitoring 89 manholes in four wards.
“One of the biggest problems is caused by household solid waste,” says Lepheana, “People are putting stuff down the toilets that should not go there (towels, old hair weaves and other items that cause blockages),” he said, adding that many people did not realise that resulting sewage leaks were polluting water in Midmar Dam, just 4km from their homes.
“People don’t always make the connection with overflows and where this water comes from. They just see it coming out of a tap at home.”
Lepheana said there had been a significant drop in blockages since the Enviro Champs began their work and awareness drives, with blockages declining from 180 cases in 2015 to less than 25 cases last year.
Residents have also been urged to stop tossing household rubbish bags into local streams if they miss the latest refuse collections by municipal rubbish trucks.
By monitoring, reporting or training residents to repair leaking taps and other household water leaks, Lepheana said residents had saved over 10 million litres of potable water during a recent three-month period. – Additional reporting, Fred Kockott
This vegetable oil storage tank collapsed at Willowton Oil, bringing down an adjacent tank. The force and weight of the collapsing tanks damaged an additional two tanks. Photo supplied
- This story, also published by GroundUp, Daily Maverick, AllAfrica.com, The Citizen and The Witness, forms part of Roving Reporters coverage of the 2019 Conservation Symposium and an associated environmental journalism programme: Developing Environmental Watchdogs – an initiative supported by the Human Elephant Foundation and Grindrod Bank